This essay Bates v. United States has a total of 1341 words and 5 pages.
Bates v. United States
In this hypothetical, the Supreme Court needs to focus on establishing the power of Congress to enact the legislation not the moral implications within the Public Accommodations Equal Access Act. In Article 1 Section 8, the Commerce Clause declares that "Congress shall have the power to regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the Indian tribes." Especially after the numerous executive orders following the New Deal, Congress has relied on the Commerce Clause to bypass the Tenth Amendment and to execute their legislative authority. This on-going controversy illustrates the difficulty of determining the equilibrium between federal and states rights. I believe the best argument follows the federal district court\'s evidence that Congress can confide in the Commerce Clause to validate the law.
Whether the framers envisioned a strong central government or not is more of a political and philosophical debate than a legal debate. The Commerce Clause can be applied to a farmer\'s production of milk that was intended only for use by the farmer that milked it and never touched interstate commerce. But the court would reason that any goods made for home use basically impacted prices on other goods because if he produced it at home, he wouldn\'t buy it somewhere else. The new millennium is battling a new discrimination of the homosexuality community just as African - Americans witnessed in the mid 20th century. So, the gay and lesbian cases are essentially the same as the civil rights cases in the 60\'s. Those cases always held that if you are a common carrier, hotel, motel, resort, gas station, restaurant, taxi, limo, bus, etc., that you may not deny service based on race, because inter-state travel impacts interstate commerce. Therefore, the Commerce Clause can say that what you are doing is an unlawful restraint on trade.
The homosexual community consists of American citizens that participate in consumption and production of interstate commerce just as anyone else would. In relation to Bates\' institution, just as stated in the example above, he feels that homosexuality is immoral. So these couples would most likely never visit this hotel and bar affecting the interstate commerce by spending their money elsewhere. In reality, Bates could be losing business by not allowing this specific clientele into his institution. On the other hand if the Equal Access Act was executed, homosexual couples could now spend their money in a new environment ultimately contributing to interstate commerce. Bates argues that his right of due process would be breached because the Equal Access Act would drastically decrease his business. Eros Lodge specifically advertises its close-knit atmosphere with a small pool catered to couples that want to spend their get-a-way together privately and with no distractions. Therefore, little social interaction would occur with the homosexuals, and the presence of the new customers would not affect the stated objective of the hotel: an escape for married couples. Some people that were surveyed said that they would never come back to Eros Lodge if homosexuals were allowed, but a new customer base would be frequenting that would make up for any loss of customers.
In the case Heart of Atlanta Motel v. United States, Congress\' power allows it to prohibit racial discrimination in hotel lodging under the Commerce Clause. The court ruled that it had the authority to control a business that even served mostly interstate customers just like Eros Lodge. Open accommodations had no right to select certain guests due to their personal or moral views on who should fit as their customers. The struggle of the racial and homosexuality issue is whether or not you can solely rest this decision upon the Commerce Clause. Homosexual marriage is legal, and they are married couples just as anyone else. In this case, however, all the court needs to base their decision on is the fact that their network of money (commerce) they use is the same as a heterosexual couple would use. The bottom line is that the Commerce Clause has been interpreted to encompass almost anything. In Katzenbach v. McClung, the cases stated that a restaurant couldn\'t discriminate against "Negros" even though the establishment was primarily a local restaurant and its food supply purchases didn\'t affect commerce. The Equal Access Act relates to
Topics Related to Bates v. United States
Commerce Clause, Heart of Atlanta Motel, Inc. v. United States, United States v. Lopez, Katzenbach v. McClung, United States v. Morrison, Article One of the United States Constitution, Hammer v. Dagenhart, Southern Pacific Railroad, Carter v. Carter Coal Co., Wickard v. Filburn
Essays Related to Bates v. United States
Plan Juridique Plan Juridique Cette partie du dossier se divise en trois parties : ? Les caract?ristiques de la SARL ? Les caract?ristiques de la g?rance, ? Les formalit?s et obligations l?gales ? suivre, ? Les statuts de la SARL ? Le Jardin des Muses ?. Nous avons choisi de cr?er une soci?t? ? responsabilit?s limit?s pour deux raisons principales : ? la responsabilit? des associ?s est limit? ? leurs apports et n?exige pas de condition de capacit? particuli?re, ? le g?rant minoritaire b?n?ficie des avantages
Gun ControlGun Control Government 2301 02 November 1996 A Well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear arms , shall not be infringed. Amendment II, Bill of Rights Constitution of the U.S. The Second Amendment has been a major issue in American politics since 1876. In question is the intent of this Amendment. Was it meant to insure that people in general have arms for personal service, or was it intended to insure arms for military service
Juidical ReviewJuidical Review In 1717, Bishop Hoadly told King George I, Whoever hath an absolute authority to interpret written or spoken laws; it is he who is truly the lawgiver to all intents and purposes and not the person who wrote or spoke them (Pollack, 153). Early sentiments similar these have blossomed in to a large scale debate over which branch of our government has the power to overturn laws that do not follow the foundations of our democratic system; the constitution. In this paper I will discu
The U.S. ConstitutionThe U.S. Constitution Article Five, clause two of the United States Constitution states, under the Authority of the United States, [the Constitution] shall be the supreme law of the land. As a result of the fact that the current activist government is pursuing inconsistent policies, many believe the Constitution has become irrelevant because no guiding principles seem to exist. Thomas Jefferson once said, The Constitution belongs to the living and not to the dead. Accordingly, it is often re
Changes To The Bill Of RightsChanges to the Bill of Rights How many rights do you have? You should check, because it might not be as many today as it was a few years ago, or even a few months ago. Some people I talk to are not concerned that police will execute a search warrant without knocking or that they set up roadblocks and stop and interrogate innocent citizens. They do not regard these as great infringements on their rights. But when you put current events together, there is information that may be surprising to peop
Civil WarCivil War IN THIS meeting of the Southern Historical Association great emphasis has been placed upon a re-examination of numerous phases of our history relating to the Civil War. While several papers have dealt with certain forces which helped bring about the Civil War, none has attempted a general synthesis of causes. This synthesis has been the task assumed by the retiring president of the Association. Before attempting to say what were the causes of the American Civil War, first let me say wh
Thomas JeffersonThomas Jefferson wished to be remembered for three achievements in his public life. He had served as governor of Virginia, as U.S. minister to France, as secretary of state under George Washington, as vice-president in the administration of John Adams, and as president of the United States from 1801 to 1809. On his tombstone, however, which he designed and for which he wrote the inscription, there is no mention of these offices. Rather, it reads that Thomas Jefferson was author of the Declarati
Due ProcessThe importance of the Supreme Court's reinterpretation of the due process concept. Before we really dive into this, I think it?s important to know what the term ?due process? is. Due process is the principle that the government must respect all of the legal rights that are owed to a person according to the law. With this, the judges (not legislators) may define and guarantee fairness, justice, and liberty. The Supreme Court?s reinterpretation of the due process clause led to an ?explosive situat
Functions and Role of Law in Business and Society Functions and Role of Law in Business and Society University of Phoenix LAW/421 Contemporary Business Law Professor Alan Williams March 2, 2015 Introduction The author of this paper will discuss the functions and role of law in business and society as well as to discuss the role of law within the automotive transport industry. According to Business Dictionary.com (2015), 1.A recognized causal link or principle whose violation must or should result in a penalty as failure, injury, loss, or pa
Bates v. United States GOV 357M 11/15/15 Bates v. United States In this hypothetical, the Supreme Court needs to focus on establishing the power of Congress to enact the legislation not the moral implications within the Public Accommodations Equal Access Act. In Article 1 Section 8, the CommerceClause declares that Congress shall have the power to regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the Indian tribes. Especially after the numerous executive orders following the New Deal,