This essay Between The Forest and Greed has a total of 857 words and 4 pages.
Between The Forest and Greed
Within the past decade there has been a rising "environmentally conscious"
movement. The spectrum of issues in contention by environmentalism has expanded
virulently and is reaching its zenith. Public dissatisfaction with the
environmental movement is forming, as the movement has taken the fight for the
environment too far. Donella Meadows is an environmentalist who has yet to
fully think about the issue she is arguing. In her piece "Not Seeing the Forest
for the Dollar Bills," she takes an almost infantile approach to the logging
industry and the concept of clear cutting. The monetary motivations behind the
logging industry is her explanation for clear cutting, trying to portray the
logging industry as a cold money making machine. This of course neglects the
fact that the reason logging generates capital is because the world needs wood.
There are several economic and environmental issues that are considered when
loggers enter and area. Haphazard clear cutting of forests, while it maybe what
Meadows would like us to think, does not happen. With every industry, every
aspect is carefully debated and analyzed for the short and long term outcomes.
Any industry that capitalizes on earth's resources figuratively signs a
pact with the earth. This pact bonds this industry to the earth and requires
that any harvesting of resources is not done so with haste and waste. There is
a symbiotic relationship between the two. For the industry to exist there must
be a constant supply of the resource. Without a constant supply the industry
dies. Now, many people believe that the logging industry's objective is to cut
down all the trees that are currently standing. As horrific as this scenario
may sound, it is far from the truth. Without trees to cut down there is no
industry. The logging industry is not so foolish as to rampage the forests and
cut down all the trees. As they cut, they plant. Replacing forests with
samplings may look inadequate, but over a long period of time these samplings
will become a new forest. The earth as we know it today has been in existence
for millions of years. Even if newly planted tress take a century to grow back
that is only a pinpoint on the time line. The millions of acres of forested
land left untouched currently will not be engulfed by blades and tractors
instantly. It will take time to cut down the trees, as it will take time to
grow them back.
Meadows seems to have a misconception of industries and the service they
provide. All industries, whether it be recycling to logging, are trying to
maximize their profits. If this means moving their plants off shore, so be it.
These industries provide the world with services that we need to operate as an
advanced civilization. She claims that the remaining old growth forests are on
protected federal land. If this is the case she has little to complain about.
The remaining portion of what she is trying to protect is protected. At the
same time she is also claiming that old growth forest can not be recreated.
This seems far fetched from the eyes of an historian. Referring back to the
history of the earth, one can assume that before humans inhabited the land that
forests burnt to the ground leaving nothing but charred remains. Yet forests
still exist today. Now, when they are threatened by fire, we save them instead
of allowing nature to take its course. Meadows gives the reader a choice
between "the forest and greed". If her choices were accurate one would probably
choose the forest. The problem lies in her choices. They are given to the
reader from only one perspective... hers. When an argument is based upon a one
sided view it loses strength. It only leads to flaws and the eventual dismissal
of the argument. In any debate one should look at the topic from the opposing
side before approaching it from one's own.
In every country, forests are considered a valuable resource. They
provide us with wood to build homes and paper to communicate. With a constantly
growing population, the need for homes becomes greater and thus the supply of
wood must also increase. The real choice that should be analyzed is "the forest
or your home". Many alternate forms of building materials are phased into the
system as need be, but the need for wood will always exist. Knowing that the
world will continue to cut down trees, the only solution to the forest depletion,
is reforestation. A forest ecologically engineered with the
Environmental ActivismEnvironmental Activism 1. The large mainstream environmentalism groups started to compromise too much with regulatory agencies and bureaus, starting with the Glen Canyon Dam project. This began an estrangement with the mainstreams that culminated in the rise of more militant groups like Earth First! Glen Canyon represented what was fundamentally wrong with the country's conservation policies: arrogant government officials motivated by a quasireligious zeal to industrialize the natural world, and
MexicoMexico Mexico was the site of some of the earliest and most advanced civilizations in the western hemisphere. The Mayan culture, according to archaeological research, attained its greatest development about the 6th century AD. Another group, the Toltec, established an empire in the Valley of Mexico and developed a great civilization still evidenced by the ruins of magnificent buildings and monuments. The leading tribe, the Aztec, built great cities and developed an intricate social, political, a
The Influence Of Green Groups On The Policy Of The United StatesThe Influence of Green Groups on the Policy of the United States Abstract: This research examines the relationship between environmental groups and the policies of the United States. The United States political system has been historically anthropocen-tric, or human centered. Environmental groups have been attempting to change this to a biocentric or ecocentric viewpoint, which includes the rights of animals and the environment. These views are nature centered instead of human centered. This stu
Steps Towards An Ecosociety: Dealing With Air PollutionSteps Towards an Ecosociety: Dealing with Air Pollution By: Jonathan Roitman For: Dr. Rao Course: Poli 385/2 This essay identifies and explains the problem of pollution facing humanity today. It will also propose one of the first ideas which could more effectively limit air pollution, Emission Credit Trading. This can be seen as one of the first steps in the development of an ecosociety. The notion of a viable ecosociety has created considerable problems in terms of deciding the most effective a
The Environmental Impact Of Eating Beef And Dairy ProductsThe Environmental Impact of Eating Beef and Dairy Products There are currently 1.28 billion cattle populating the earth. They occupy nearly 24 percent of the landmass of the planet. Their combined weight exceeds that of the earth's entire human population. Raising cows for beef has been linked to several environmental problems, and eating beef can worsen your health. The Dairy Industry puts not only your health in danger from consuming their products, but the lives of the cows that produce them.
TemagamiTemagami Table of Contents Introduction 2 The History of the Forest 2 The Forests of Canada 3 Part One: The History of the Logger 5 The Canadian Forestry Industry 5 The Ontario Forestry Industry 7 Part Two: Forest Conservation in Ontario 8 Political Activity 8 Temagami 9 Part Three: The Temagami Debate 11 The Forester 11 The Environmentalist 12 Part Four: The Law of the Land 13 Civil Disobedience 13 Government Legislation / Wildlands League Lawsuit 15 Natural vs. Positive Law 16 Conclusion 17 Su
ReforestationReforestation The purpose of this written report is to inform the reader about the concerns and facts involved with reforestation. Reforestation began in Ontario after World War II. What happened was, professional foresters were assigned to an area and became responsible for its well being. Under the Crown Timber Act, long term management was prepared. Then the many steps needed to rebuild a forest began. Included in this report will be information on the effects of cutting and replanting, such
Predators And Ecosystem ManagementPredators and Ecosystem Management Natural Resources Management 01/29/97 Predators have an everlasting effect on different kinds of ecosystems. They influence there ecosystems by controlling the abundance of lower species certain habitats. In this article, ?Predators and Ecosystem Management? by (James A. Estes). He explains results of case studies that indicate important ecological roles for predators in a huge coastal ecosystem. The main challenge in this article is to determine if there are r
OzoneOzone Ozone (O3) is a molecule consisting of three oxygen atoms, similar to the oxygen we breathe (O2), however oxygen consists of only two oxygen atoms. In the stratosphere, a region high up in the upper atmosphere, light rays are responsible for the breaking down of oxygen (O2), breathable oxygen into its two separate oxygen atoms. Lone oxygen atoms are markedly reactive. When a lone oxygen atom comes into contact with a breathable oxygen molecule (O2) it combines to form ozone (O3). The ozone
Management Techniques For The Red-Cockaded Woodpecker On Federal LandsManagement Techniques For The Red-Cockaded Woodpecker On Federal Lands Sean Fraser NRM 304 ABSTRACT The red-cockaded woodpecker (Picoides borealis) has been listed as an endangered species since October, 1970. This species inhabits pine forests in the southeastern United States where the majority of prime timberland is privately owned. Private ownership of preferred habitat and historically destructive silvicultural practices create unique problems for federal wildlife managers. This report anal
Global Economy And The EnvironmentGlobal Economy and the Environment As the global economy gets integrated, national or local corporations will gradually transform in to a multinational corporation (MNC). When this type of development occurs, the host countries are usually the ones that become the immediate stake holders. This is because when a MNC sets its foot into a host country, there are economic, political, social and environmental impacts that result from their corporate actions. In many cases, it is certainly possible th
Global WarmingGlobal Warming Mission Plan a. Analysis of the Problem 1. History of the Problem Some scientist's have been concerned since 1896 about what might happen if there were 5.5 billion tons carbon dioxide in our atmosphere. In 1961 a British scientist did an experiment showing that the carbon in the air was absorbing some of the sun's radiation. Afterward a Swedish scientist, Suante Arrhenius, found out if the radiation of the sun was trapped in the carbon dioxide the temperature of the earth would in
Deforestation Of The Pacific NorthwestDeforestation of the Pacific Northwest One of the most controversial areas associated with the global problem of deforestation is the Pacific Northwest of the US. The problem can be broken down into several issues that all tie in together. These include the near extinction of the Northern Spotted Owl, the business aspect of logging versus the environmental aspect, and the role of the government in this problem. In 1973, the Endangered Species Act (ESA) was passed. This enabled the Dept. of Com
The Enviromnetal Degradation As A Result Of OverpopulationThe Enviromnetal Degradation as a Result of Overpopulation 1 Introduction There are simply too many people on our planet, and the population is not showing any signs of slowing down(see Figure 1). It is having disastrous effects on our environment. There are too many implications and interrelationships to discuss in this paper, but the three substances that our earth consists of: land, water and air, are being destroyed. Our forests are being cut down at an alarming rate, bearing enormous impact
Forest Policy In MalaysiaForest Policy in Malaysia Malaysia is among the countries in Southeast Asia which has experienced remarkable economic growth and industrialization in the past decade. It is unique in that its success is not a result of adopting any one model for development. Rather, Malaysia?s government identified its goals and sought to create a country-specific model of development suited to their needs for growth. An example of this is the Malaysian government?s increase in exports of manufactured goods rath
The Abstract WildThe Abstract Wild Jack Turner?s The Abstract Wild is a complex argument that discusses many issues and ultimately defends the wild in all of its forms. He opens the novel with a narrative story about a time when he explored the Maze in Utah and stumbled across ancient pictographs. Turner tells this story to describe what a truly wild and unmediated experience is. The ideas of the aura, magic, and wildness that places contain is introduced in this story. Turner had a spiritual connection with the
kjlJournal of the Kuala Lumpur Royal Malaysia Police College, No. 3, 2004 CRIME PREVENTION DCP Walter J. Rugbere1 INTRODUCTION I intend to approach this topic from an underlying philosophical impulse, which I have found useful as a springboard for take-off, each time there is an opportunity to examine the issue of crime prevention. It is my view that the legitimacy and authority of the state over the people can be sustained only to the extent it can guarantee the security of life and property of th
Corn MotherThe Corn Mother Traditions were an important part of Indian society that were often started with a spark from a single story. Most of the tribes of the eastern American woodlands were polytheistic. Popular beliefs were in many gods and mythical figures; those ?gods? having the power to either curse a tribe or help it prosper. The Corn Mother was one of these mythical figures. She was known to be a beautiful woman from whom corn came from. She was legendary and many traditions and customs evolved
The New DealThe New Deal Following the Great Depression, President Roosevelt Franklin was elected in 1932. Upon his election to deliver the New Deal, an unprecedented number of reforms addressing the catastrophic effects of the Great Depression, Roosevelt felt it was the federal governmentís duty to help the American people weather these bad times. His first duty as president was to declare a four-day bank Holiday, during which time congress drafted the Emergency Banking Bill of 1933, which stabilized the B
Sustainable approaches to landfill diversion: the global sustainabiliSustainable approaches to landfill diversion: the global sustainability of deconstruction United States Army Corps of Engineers, Engineering Research and Development Center-Construction Engineering Research Laboratory-Champaign, IL, USA Concurrent Technologies Corporation-Largo, FL, USA University of the Pacific-Stockton, CA, USA ABSTRACT: This paper provides analysis that higher diversion rates of construction and demolition (C&D) waste from the U.S. landfill sites are not only good from a sust
AP Human Geography OutlineAP Human Geography Outline Ch. 1 Thinking Geographically Key Issue 1: How do geographers describe where things are? Map- a two-dimensional model of Earthís surface, or a portion of it. Place- a specific point of Earth distinguished by a particular character. Region- an area of Earth distinguished by a distinctive combination of cultural and physical features. Scale- the relationship between a mapís distances and the actual distances on Earth. Space- the physical gap between two objects. Connecti
Chapter 9 Case Study : Chapter 9 Case Study : Instructions : Read the Case Study, view the film, then answer¬†ONE¬†of the questions, using information from the film, Case Study, and textbook. Across Russia's many landscapes, geography influences the problems people face and the solutions they are considering since the dissolution of the Soviet Union. 1.¬† Define¬†continentality. What factors of continentality affect Vologda? 2.¬†¬†Explain the role of collective farming in the centrally planned economy of the former S