This essay Democracy's Failure in Pakistan has a total of 1394 words and 7 pages.
Democracy\'s Failure in Pakistan
Why India is democratic and Pakistan is not. What after all is wrong with Pakistan?
On their emergence as two independent states on the map of the world as a result of a democratic political process, both India and Pakistan inherited a parliamentary tradition and began their independent statehood with a democratic path clearly charted out for them. To start with, however, there was no level-playing field for the state of Pakistan which had to build an entire government from the scratch in 1947 under a state of emergency whereas India was born with an intact bureaucratic apparatus in Delhi.
The Congress emerged virtually as a mini-parliament with democratic habits of debate, argument and negotiation.
Since then, India managed to forge an uninterrupted democratic tradition by adopting its constitution in 1950, going through political and economic reforms and despite its huge size and socio-economic challenges, holding elections every five years.
In Pakistan, the vision of a democratic and progressive future articulated unambiguously in a resolution adopted by the Council of the Pakistan Muslim League in December 1947 remains an ever illusory goal. With its Founder\'s early demise in September 1948, the new State of Pakistan lost the promise of healthy political growth with acute systemic deficiencies restricting its transition to democracy.
After the Quaid, it was left without any sense of direction, and came to be possessed by a corrupt political hierarchy of no more than a bunch of self-serving, feudalist and opportunistic politicians who were to manage the newly independent Pakistan in collusion with civil and military bureaucracy. In the process, we saw a continuing cycle of governmental changes by non-political means. Machiavelli\'s political philosophy based on the "doctrine of necessity," became an integral part of our body politic.
Given the common history of the \'twin\' neighbours, one wonders why India is democratic and Pakistan is not. What after all is wrong with Pakistan? For us, it is not sufficient only to attribute Pakistan\'s failure in democracy to its leadership miscarriages and military take-overs. There are in fact deep-rooted historical, socio-cultural and geo-political factors that have been conditioning the post-independence democratic tradition in Pakistan. Since independence, the politics and governments in Pakistan have also remained hostage to the feudal-led elite classes which have been inimical to any far-reaching political reform or liberalization in the country.
The overbearing feudal power structure in Pakistan is the main cause of our political decay.
It has always resisted land reforms in the country which it fears will strike at its own roots. Unlike India\'s Congress Party, the Muslim League, Pakistan\'s founding party was almost wholly dominated by few feudal families, which the British had patronised before partition and were powerful enough to retain control over national affairs through the bureaucracy and the armed forces. Even after Muslim League\'s disintegration, the same feudalised oligarchy consisting of different men at different times under different political flags remained in power with or without military collaboration
Historically too, Pakistan was handicapped in developing a democratic tradition.
In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the British had been gradually devolving power to local authorities in several provinces across India but those reforms were never extended to the North-West Frontier Province and Punjab, the territories that later made up the bulk of Pakistan after the 1947 partition. Thus several of the provinces India inherited from the Raj already had some experience in democracy, Pakistan inherited two highly militarized provinces with no such tradition. This unpalatable colonial legacy in conjunction with the country\'s feudalised political parties, social conservatism, and outside influences provided a fertile ground for Pakistan\'s army to grow in size and scale and gain an increasingly strong influence over the state.
There are in fact deep-rooted historical, socio-cultural and geo-political factors that have been conditioning the post-independence democratic tradition in Pakistan. Since independence, the politics and governments in Pakistan have also remained hostage to the feudal-led elite classes.
The most important factor circumscribing democracy\'s growth in Pakistan, however, has been its geopolitical location which not only shaped its post-independence personality as a state but also conditioned its domestic as well as external behaviour.
Emerging from the trauma of sub-continental turmoil, the young state of Pakistan, faced with the stark reality
Topics Related to Democracy's Failure in Pakistan
Political history of Pakistan, Iranian Plateau, Pakistan, Pakistan Movement, West Pakistan, PakistanUnited States relations
Essays Related to Democracy's Failure in Pakistan
PakistanPakistan Steve Olker Core 132 Pakistan is a country that, since its creation, has been rooted in turmoil. The recent years are no exception to this. Since 1988, power has been divided among the president, the prime minister and the military. Tensions between the three, however, have led to eight changes of government and three elections. No elected leader has ever completed a full term in office. Benazir Bhutto, who was dismissed by the president in August 1990 after only twenty-one months in o
Worlds Longest WarWorld's Longest War The World's Longest War Where We Are Journals practice a laudable self-censorship of criticism of religions. The most vicious devil worship is mentioned with little comment and then only in crime reporting of the atrocities committed. This is a good thing. Religious hatreds are so easily inflamed, and there is so much history of religious persecution, that we are much better off with this self restraint. Furthermore the separation of church and state is spelled out in our con
HinduismHinduism Hinduism Introduction Hinduism is a religion that originated in India and is still practiced by most of the Natives as well as the people who have migrated from India to other parts of the world. Statistically there are over seven hundred million Hindus, mainly in Bharat, India and Nepal. Eighty five percent of the population in India is Hindu. The word Hindu comes from an ancient Sanskrit term meaning dwellers by the Indus River, referring to the location of India's earliest know civ
Nuclear StrikesNuclear Strikes Scientifically, there is no obstacle for a nuclear or atomic bomb. There are no secrets in Nuclear Science anymore. Anyone with a reasonable physics degree and access to a good technical library could design a workable atomic bomb in less than 6 months, so why hasn't anyone. Maybe there has been, no one is exactly sure. In the last 52 years there has been enough nuclear warheads made to destroy every city in the world and still have thousands left over.(Church 40) This all happen
Nuclear WeaponsNuclear Weapons A major problem concerning the world today is the disposal of nuclear weapons. With the Cold War, we have seen a massive build up of nuclear weapons, and no, that we are no longer in a state of global warfare, what is to be done with them? As a result of the build-up in nuclear weapons during the cold war the world is now facing major environmental problems trying to deactivate them, and in addition major debate are occurring on the policies of disarmament and deterrence as solut
Comparative Politics Comparative Politics Comparative Politics, typically defined as the study of the internal politics of nations other than our own, is a diverse and complex field. There is no one central tendency or approach which dominates this area of inquiry within political science: various theories, concepts, issues and methodologies are evident in the field. While it is recognized that no simple classification can be made of the literature, we are encouraged to be aware of contrasting approaches, and to en
ShameShame Criticism of Shame Shame, published in 1983, a year before his most famous work The Satanic Verses, presents a fabulistic account in a country that disturbingly represents Pakistan. Critically, Shame is compared to Midnight?s Children because the of its resemblances in themes and style. The idea for Shame, reported interviewer Ronal Hayman in Books and Bookmen, grew out of Rushdie?s interest in the Pakistani concept of sharam, a word that denotes a hybrid of embarrassment, discomfiture, de
Women\'s Reproductive Rights and Marital Rights: A Comparison of TwentWomen\'s Reproductive Rights and Marital Rights: A Comparison of Twenty Countries As early as 1871, Elizabeth Cady Stanton recognized that suffrage alone would not guarantee women?s emancipation. Rather, she noted that in order for a woman to be a truly equal and independent citizen, she must possess the ability to control her own circumstances. The pride of every man is that he is free to carve out his own destiny. A woman has no such pride (DuBois, 1981:140). Through this recognition she acc
Censorship is sometimes justified Censorship is sometimes justified OUTLINE Introduction; what is censorship? The right to freedom of thought and expression is protected by laws and constitutions The freedom to read is essential to the democratic way of life. Why censorship is necessary -to avoid brutal acts and violence on the hands of government -to protect the rights of illetrate massess -to maintain peace and harmony in the society Reforms for making censor acts more acceptable -protection of civil rights -necessity of trut
Democracy's Failure in Pakistan Democracy\'s Failure in Pakistan Why India is democratic and Pakistan is not. What after all is wrong with Pakistan? On their emergence as two independent states on the map of the world as a result of a democratic political process, both India and Pakistan inherited a parliamentary tradition and began their independent statehood with a democratic path clearly charted out for them. To start with, however, there was no level-playing field for the state of Pakistan which had to build an entire gov
WOMEN AND PARTITION WOMEN AND PARTITION S. Sibi Tales of war are generally constituted with dividing lines, two established sides, crusade and commands. But, the Indian partition proved otherwise. What makes it different? After the announcement of independence for India in 1947, the world witnessed the largest movement for resettlement in the history of humanity triggered by the new state borders. The accord of history agrees that around 12.5 million people residing in India-Pakistan at that time were dislocated a
THE 1947 PARTITION OVERLOOKED IN THE FIELD OF CINE THE 1947 PARTITION OVERLOOKED IN THE FIELD OF CINEMA -S. Sibi Partition of Indian PakistanÂ in the year of 1947 is the only disturbingÂ occurrence in Indian History which influenced all the facets of Social Science - History, Civics, Geography and Economics. Movies being a potent medium to convey the social plight, few movie makers have successfully portrayed them over celluloid too. Some are the adaptation from Novels where protagonist\'s life seems to be majorly impacted by aftermath and some
AP Human Geography OutlineAP Human Geography Outline Ch. 1 Thinking Geographically Key Issue 1: How do geographers describe where things are? Map- a two-dimensional model of Earth’s surface, or a portion of it. Place- a specific point of Earth distinguished by a particular character. Region- an area of Earth distinguished by a distinctive combination of cultural and physical features. Scale- the relationship between a map’s distances and the actual distances on Earth. Space- the physical gap between two objects. Connecti